|
John
Cocks, engineer comments...
Effectiveness
- Friom
what is seen in the photo an effective device has been
built. A description about how it functions is important
to explain why it has been built this way and how it works.
Durability
- Some
plastices deteriorate in sunshine. Without having more
detail we can't comment on the durability of the system
- that is the materials and how the connections fit together
and will last. Tape
breaks down easily.
User-friendliness
- It
coud be user friendly by appearance but we don't know
because of the lack of description and maybe some user
comments.
John
la Roche comments on the prototype design added after
John Cocks had given feedback...
Stephanie,
Kate and Annabel, you have obviously put a lot of
thought into your design. However I think that if
you build it there would be a number of problems.
From
a hygiene point of view having to pull out the plug with
dirty hands would contaminate it. Unless it is also
thoroughly washed in the limited water supply available,
the user will re-contaminate her/his hands when they put
the plug back.
I can see why you have thought of a divider to limit the
quantity of water - a very good idea for a water short
place like many villages and schools in PNG.
However I suggest it would be difficult to seal the
slider without fairly sophisticated rubber seals that
would be subject to wear and deterioration. If you
did not have good seals and the slider leaked,
you would loose the precious water.
Your
idea of having soap inside the tube would help in washing
very dirty hands, but I suspect the soap might become
soft and block the tube. Normally it would be a
good idea to use a cleanser on the hands first, and then
wash off with water. Having the soap already in
the tube would not allow a final rinse. A cleanser
often used by pioneers was dry wood ashes (cold)
from the fire to rub on their hands before washing.
Wood ashes are a very effective cleanser.
Most houses in PNG have no electricity and they do their
cooking with wood fires so there would be no problem to
get wood ashes.
You
have some very good thoughts on how to deal with a difficult
problem, but I feel your design calls for some more refinement before
it could work effectively.
Prof
Norris comments...
Communication
- I don't think you have quite worked out who your audience
is. Mollenberg bread with lettuce & ham might make
the people in PNG wonder. This is a clear message for
New Zealanders but not people from PNG. Also, from the
photo, the little boy doens't look too ill to me. The
toilet is a Western one. Some of the photos are really
cute but over all they are not relevant to PNG.
|